The so-called Nass on Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb is false. Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb’s ‘Nass’ episode was fabricated by the anti-Qutbuddin group. Taking advantage of Syedna Burhanuddin’s ill health and communication difficulties Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb and some other shehzadas have put words into Huzurala’s mouth. Syedna Burhanuddin has never said that Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb is his Mansoos; no one has ever heard him say this.
Soon after Syedna Burhanuddin’s hundredth birthday, he suffered a severe stroke in London, and was hospitalized. Having been unsuccessful in their attempts at getting Syedna Qutbuddin dismissed from the post of Mazoon, which in this instance they knew was linked to the higher post of successor, the Shehzadas group, by now fully integrated in their belief, thinking, and malignant actions with the children of Fatema Aisaheba, took full advantage of Syedna Burhanuddin’s debilitating condition and staged a full fledged succession drama.
After the stroke—the doctors say—it was impossible that Syedna Burhanuddin proclaimed the ‘Nass’ as the Shehzada’s describe.
Shehzada Qaid Johar Bhaisaheb narrated the sequence of events to mumineen in a majlis in the London masjid the next afternoon and said that Syedna had gathered Shehzada Idris Bhaisab, Shehzada Qusai Bhaisab and Shehzada Ammar Bhaisab around his bed in the hospital the previous day. He had sat upright in the bed (a few hours after suffering a severe stroke at the age of 100), and pronounced in a clear and loud voice that he was appointing Shahzada Mufaddal Bhaisaheb as his successor after him, and that this appointment should be made public, effective immediately.
Shehzada Qaid Johar Bhaisab and Shehzada Mufaddal Bhaisab himself, who were both in London, not more than a few minutes’ drive from the hospital, were, according to this version of events, not called by Syedna Burhanuddin to give this momentous news and instruction. Shz Qaid Johar Bhaisab went later to the hospital. All the shehzadas then collectively went to Bonham house, Syedna Burhanuddin’s residence in London, only a few minutes away from the hospital, and informed Shehzada Mufaddal bhaisaheb, who it seems was very much taken aback and unaware of Syedna Burhanuddin’s decision to appoint him, let alone to announce it to the public.
There are several problems with this version of events. First, that only a few hours after suffering this debilitating stroke, Syedna was able to sit upright in his bed and pronounce in a loud and clear voice his instructions, when even 15 days later in Rozat Tahera, even though the microphone was put in front of Syedna, not one of thousands of people understood one word that he spoke. Second, why did Syedna not call Shz Qaidjohar bhaisaheb and Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb to the hospital before announcing this momentous decision when they were only minutes away. Especially Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb, who was the apparent appointee himself. Third, no audio or video recording of this momentous event has been released, whereas Shz Idris bhaisaheb whenever he is present in an event, even if it is in the home of Syedna, releases photos on the internet.
15 days later, on the urus of Syedna Taher Saifuddin, 19th Rajab 1432H, the shehzadas group flew Syedna all the way over from London, in this condition where he had just very recently had a debilitating stroke at this advanced age [WHY?! Was not the care and health of Syedna Burhanuddin to take priority at that time?]. They brought him for one purpose only, because they wanted to get the rubber stamp of approval on their unconvincing announcement of nass. They brought Syedna Burhanuddin to Rozat Tahera, and sat him down outside the Roza in a gathering of thousands of mumineen. They put the microphone in front of Syedna Burhanuddin, however no one could understand any words. Dr. Moiz bhaisaheb, Syedna Burhanuddin’s son-in-law, and closest caregiver, ostensibly repeated what Syedna Burhanuddin was saying so everyone could understand, all the while reading from a paper he held in his hands. In the official letter communicating the ‘Nass’ sent out a few months later, the conspirators were left with no choice but to acknowledge that it was Dr Moiz Bhaisaheb’s so-called interpretation of Syedna Burhanuddin’s words that mumineen heard.
Then Dr. Moiz bhaisaheb asked Shz Mufaddal bs to come and do qadambosi of Syedna. Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb stood in front of Syedna for several minutes with no reaction from Huzurala. Dr. Moiz bhaisaheb then repeatedly did araz to Syedna that Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb was standing in front of him.
In the following three years, Shahzada Mufaddal bhaisaheb and his supporters brought Syedna Burhanuddin in public on various occasions inspite of his delicate condition. They even brought him on Ashura for all the following 3 Ashuras, and even put the microphone in front of him during all those Ashuras, including the first one after the declaration of the supposed nass. Syedna not once, not even on the first of those Ashuras, mentioned or proclaimed his appointment of Shehzada Mufaddal Bhaisab as his successor.
Sh Malik-ul-Ashtar bhaisaheb said to Syedna Qutbuddin directly in Ramadan 1434 that “kai bhi araz nahi thai sakti”, there is no communication with Syedna Burhanuddin. Then he himself went on to say a few days later in Laylatul Qadar in a public speech in front of Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb that was relayed worldwide, that Mein hamna hazrat ma si aayo anay Syedna Burhanuddin said this and this and this…(see video near end of page). Based on his own earlier admission to Syedna Qutbuddin that it was not possible to araz to Syedna Burhanuddin, it is clear that he was putting words in Syedna Burhanuddin’s mouth. This is exactly what they have been doing all along—putting words into Syedna Burhanuddin’s mouth—in claiming Nass on Shz Mufaddal bhaisaheb. So their shahaadat cannot be counted.